Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Monday, January 30
    Facebook LinkedIn
    Login
    eBizRadio.com Online RadioeBizRadio.com Online Radio
    • Home
    • Listen Live!
    • Podcast
    • Categories
      • Biz Entrepreneur
      • Biz Insight
      • Biz Opinion
      • Biz Research
      • Biz Trends
      • Biz Wires
      • Marketing Biz
      • Motoring Biz
      • Productivity Biz
      • Retail Biz
      • Techno Biz
      • Travel Biz
      • Tales from my Stethoscope
    • Advertise/Contact
    Trending
    • Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast
    • Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast
    • What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group
    • How a small NPO School is providing Quality Education and making all the difference to the future of South Africa | #Education | #ECD | #NGO | The Love Trust | Nokuphila Schoo
    • Preparing learners with the skills they need to take jobs in the future? | #Technology | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Lindi Tshabangu | Richard Osei-Anim | Coralreef Innovation Hub | #Podcast
    • How is AI and possibly ChatGPT disrupting marketing? | #Marketing | #AI | #ChatGPT | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast
    • Motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success | #Business | #Coaching | Kevin Britz | Desiree Wegner | The Holistic People Collective | #Podcast
    • Teaching children emotional intelligence | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Word of Mouth | Lindi Tshabangu | Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali | Zamangwane Foundation | #Podcast
    eBizRadio.com Online RadioeBizRadio.com Online Radio
    Home»Article»Why are many BPC Embedded projects unsuccessful? |#Technology |#Trends |#B2B |#Emiliyan Tanev
    Article

    Why are many BPC Embedded projects unsuccessful? |#Technology |#Trends |#B2B |#Emiliyan Tanev

    eBizRadioBy eBizRadioSeptember 10, 2019Updated:September 10, 2019No Comments7 Mins Read
    Emiliyan Tanev, Principal SAP BPC Consultant, at Decision Inc. UK
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Business Planning and Consolidation (BPC) Embedded has been offered by SAP for some time now and yet, general perception in the industry is that many have not achieved the success that they set out to achieve. In this article, I am outlining some of the reasons why some BPC Embedded solutions have not succeeded. The first step is to look at the history of the product.

    SAP BPC Embedded: A History – BPC Embedded emerged as a new product when BPC 10.1 was released back in 2014. The Embedded environment was, and still is, only available on the NetWeaver platform that runs on the SAP HANA database. A few months after the initial release, a sub-project was released in the form of BPC Optimised for S4/HANA. This had the same internal workings but came pre-delivered with standard templates that were designed to increase the speed of adoption.

    A few years later, in 2016, the Consolidation functionality was released for BPC Embedded and this led to the release of yet another product – BPC Optimised for S4/HANA Real Time Consolidation (RTC). The consolidation engine from BPC Standard was ported to BPC Embedded to provide customers with a single, unified Embedded environment that was capable of doing both Planning and Consolidation more effectively.

    Today, when we talk about BPC Embedded, it is important to clarify that more than 90% of the software product is essentially the BW-IP (Business Warehouse – Integrated Planning) solution, the rest consists of specific functionalities from BPC Standard. These include work status, business process flows, and data access profiles. For the consolidation models, the heritage of BPC Standard is slightly more notable thanks to the Business Rule engine for the consolidation logic from Standard.

    The backbone of BPC Embedded is BW-IP was released in 2005 and was the primary offering for comprehensive planning from SAP. Interestingly BW-IP was competing with OutlookSoft before SAP bought Outlooksoft in 2007. Later, OutlookSoft was rebranded as BPC and then, with Embedded in the line-up, to BPC Standard. The main appeal of the OutlookSoft product was the balance it achieved between flexibility and complexity. It was far less technically complex that BW-IP and, because of that, it was relatively easy for a professional with a business background to grasp the fundamentals in a short period of time. Professionals with business background and limited technical skills can develop and architect successful solutions and this was, and still is, a key driver for the success stories that sit behind BPC. It is doubtful that the same can be said for BW-IP, even today.

    The Benefits of BPC Embedded – So, you’re probably asking why BPC-IP remains a key option in the planning product line-up from SAP if there are limited success stories. Actually, in many cases, it remains a preferred choice over BPC Standard and SAP Analytics Cloud. The reason for this is the numerous benefits that walk hand-in-hand with BPC Embedded. I’m not going to name them all as that would take far too long to read, but the key advantages are:

    • Analysis for Office is lighter than EPM add-in workbooks
    • A comprehensive toolset of the BW Queries 
    • Active data locking keeping the data integrity
    • Fantastic performance of AMDP/SQL Script logic
    • Little to no data redundancy, if done right
    • Real-Time access to source data from S4
    • Shared master data across the whole BW landscape
    • The option of being the Enterprise Reporting tool
    • Much nicer user experience in a cross-model environment
    • The capability of matrix security
    • Out of the box “what if” modelling 
    • Out of the box comprehensive disaggregation functionality
    • Plan on key figures backed by real master data with dropdowns
    • Multi-key figure modelling

    The Complexity – All these benefits come at a price and this happens to be the higher technical complexity. This stems from the fact that BW-IP uses lower-level components that allow for more flexibility, while most of the BPC Standard components on NetWeaver are mapped to predefined BW objects. There are a few exceptions such as: Member Formulas, Business Process Flows, Consolidation Engine, and Logic Script specific to BPC Standard.

    This means that when you build BPC Standard components, you work a level of abstraction higher than BW-IP/BPC Embedded. For example, the BW queries required in BPC Embedded for creating input forms are replaced by one BW query per model in BPC Standard, as set by the system out of the box. Due to that limitation in the query building, BPC Standard has more versatility with EPM add-in.

    However, by pushing the functionality from the BW query to a workbook, the system needs to move the primary data processing a layer above. The capabilities of EPM add-in has its benefit in line of business-driven systems, but inevitably makes the EPM add-in heavier. As a result, this affects performance. However, in smaller environments with smaller sets of master and transaction data and light formatting on the workbooks, the difference in performance is immaterial. Similarly, the BPC Standard model creation is quite limited as it is mapped to specific types of BW components. This makes the BPC Standard build engine take decisions on behalf of what has been created in BW. This makes the build process even more straightforward, but it does limit the functionality. For example, you may have a case for a multi-key figure model or planning on key figures backed by master data, rather than just numeric values.

    The topic of complexity is more profound than the shared examples above and, admittedly the article has only scratched the surface. However, the main take-away related to a BPC Embedded project should be the higher volume of design decisions and components to be configured compared with BPC Standard. As a result, the price of more flexibility is paid by considerably more complexity.

    The Key to Success – Due to the technical complexities, many professionals with business backgrounds struggle to learn it, and to therefore contribute to the design of the BPC Embedded solution. Inevitably, any solution led exclusively by technical people will frequently miss important functionalities and this will then knock on to more development cycles and patching work. The consequence of that includes budget overruns, trade-offs and an unhappy user base.

    To mitigate these challenges, it is essential to have both a team with the right blend of skills combined with exceptional communication for the successful implementation of a SAP EPM solution. Efficient collaboration is a critical success factor and often having remote working team mates can prove to be challenging. By default, team members should have in-depth knowledge of the solution based on real life experience. Building comprehensive, lengthy, proof of concepts is helpful, but real project expertise is a significant benefit.

    Having business people with technical skills and technical people with business skills. This makes the team members capable of asking the right questions, seeking collaboration in the right moments and contributing substantially to the design of the solution. It is worth emphasising again that the key difference of the Embedded project is the technical proficiency required by the team. I consider the business, project management, soft skills and client involvement just as critical, of course, but they are critical to the success of any project.

    In short, BPC Embedded projects are challenging and complex, but if done successfully they can deliver a lot of value to the users and to the company implementing them.

    Behind the scenes at Decision Inc. – a global leader in information-driven transformation with a core focus on data, digital and performance intelligence. Our expertise in technology and industry specialisations have enabled us to help companies around the world make better decisions faster. Our emphasis on local excellence and global scale enables us to bring clients best of breed technology solutions that enable significant improvement whilst leveraging our Global Research and Innovation teams to accelerate the time to insight. Our local consulting teams are experts in the implementation, support and execution of these solutions and work with our clients to deliver real results and improvement.

    Post Views: 3,439
    Decision Inc Emiliyan Tanev
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
    eBizRadio
    • Website

    eBizRadio is a live multi- platformed social media service providing an online forum to the business community for holding conversations on the key issues related to specific businesses as well as availing a space for cross-business collaboration in response to key issues affecting the world of business. The place to go if you want to know about business and lifestyle

    Related Posts

    Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast

    January 30, 2023

    Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast

    January 29, 2023

    What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group

    January 25, 2023

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    STREAMING 24/7

    The Stream is up 24/7 with a few exceptions for maintenance. We focus on business news and inisghts for the African Marketplace

    If you miss anything on the live STREAM, don’t worry as all our interviews are all available for download as PODCASTS and you can SHARE them with your network – it’s FREE!

    Contact us: 063 002 5148

    Our Most Recent Podcasts
    eBizRadio.com Online Radio
    eBizRadio.com Online Radio
    Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast
    00:00 / 1929
    RSS Feed
    Share
    Link
    Embed
    • Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast

      Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast

      Jan 30, 2023 • 1929

      A Unique Selling Proposition (USP) is a crucial aspect of any business that sets it apart from its competitors. It is the factor that makes a business memorable, trustworthy and desirable to its target market. Once a business owner has discovered their USP, they can offer their clients real and…

    • Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast

      Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast

      Jan 29, 2023 • 40.44

      The world is witnessing massive job losses in 2023, with tech-based companies being particularly impacted. Many organizations are announcing their intentions to lay off more staff, with the common reasons cited as the pandemic boom, over hiring during the pandemic, fear of recession, and inflation. Cost-cutting, subpar performance, and financial…

    • What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group

      What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group

      Jan 25, 2023 • 33.40

      Handle your recruitment with care. Its hard to have those tough conversations with your team, but its how and where do you it that will make the difference. Welcome to the era of human leadership. According to a survey done by Gartner, 90% of HR execs believe that to be…

    • Preparing learners with the skills they need to take jobs in the future? | #Technology | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Lindi Tshabangu | Richard Osei-Anim | Coralreef Innovation Hub | #Podcast

      Preparing learners with the skills they need to take jobs in the future? | #Technology | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Lindi Tshabangu | Richard Osei-Anim | Coralreef Innovation Hub | #Podcast

      Jan 24, 2023 • 22.04

      While Automation is phasing out traditional job roles innovation is redefining these jobs and creating new ones. The burden of responsibility is thus placed on Education to prepare learners with the skills they need to take up these jobs of the future. Lindi Tshabangu, host of the entrepreneur show –…

    • How is AI and possibly ChatGPT disrupting marketing? | #Marketing | #AI | #ChatGPT | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee |  Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      How is AI and possibly ChatGPT disrupting marketing? | #Marketing | #AI | #ChatGPT | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Jan 20, 2023 • 37.54

      Is AI and possibly even ChatGPT the big disruptive movement in the marketing space? Kevin Britz and Craig Page-Lee, host the weekly Lunchtime Marketing show on www.ebizradio.com and for the first show of 2023, they delve into the big trends for 2023, particularly looking at AI.   Post Views: 3,439

    • Motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success | #Business | #Coaching | Kevin Britz | Desiree Wegner | The Holistic People Collective | #Podcast

      Motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success | #Business | #Coaching | Kevin Britz | Desiree Wegner | The Holistic People Collective | #Podcast

      Jan 19, 2023 • 35.34

      Periodically, we encounter difficulty in finding inspiration for our pursuits. Though there may be brief periods of motivation, it can eventually dissipate, causing us to fall behind in our goals. What many fail to realize is that motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success. Without it, there is no…

    • Teaching children emotional intelligence | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Word of Mouth | Lindi Tshabangu | Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali |  Zamangwane Foundation | #Podcast

      Teaching children emotional intelligence | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Word of Mouth | Lindi Tshabangu | Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali | Zamangwane Foundation | #Podcast

      Jan 17, 2023 • 24.20

      Social entrepreneur, author, teacher, mother and the epitome of Ubuntu.  How we can collectively assist our children to grow, develop, communicate and develop into emotionally intelligent, confident and secure your adults. Lindi Tshabangu connect with Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali, founder of  Zamangwane Foundation to find out more about this entrepreneur, her…

    • Its time to re-evaluate your values | #Insight | #Business | Lunchtime Coaching | Kevin Britz | Kiona van Griensven

      Its time to re-evaluate your values | #Insight | #Business | Lunchtime Coaching | Kevin Britz | Kiona van Griensven

      Jan 16, 2023 • 32.39

      Are you tired of saying, I’m overwhelmed, I’m exhausted, how am I going to cope with and in business this year? You are so not alone, but we need to adjust and change  how we do things, what is important to us and how do we re-evaluate our entire business…

    • Stop it now! |#BrandActivism | #Marketing | #Branding | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Stop it now! |#BrandActivism | #Marketing | #Branding | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Dec 15, 2022 • 41.40

      Brand activism is when a brand or business takes a stand on a social, environmental, economic, or political issue. It’s about supporting a cause that aligns with a company’s core values, communicating a commitment to creating a positive impact, and putting that commitment into action. Brand activism is what you…

    • Calling Us Home - The Musical - Meet the cast | #Entertainment | #Music | #Theatre | Bjorn Salsone | Devonecia Swartz | Michael Castillo | #Podcast

      Calling Us Home - The Musical - Meet the cast | #Entertainment | #Music | #Theatre | Bjorn Salsone | Devonecia Swartz | Michael Castillo | #Podcast

      Dec 15, 2022 • 15.57

      After a thrilling audition process and nationwide search in South Africa as well as New York, Shy Music are delighted to announce that the leading roles in Calling Us Home – The Musical have been confirmed for the premiere season in Cape Town in February 2023, before the grand-scale musical…

    • Go out and do what is right for you | #Entrepreneur | #Business | #Purpose | Bjorn Salsone | Nomalanga Sitole |The Voice Within #Podcast

      Go out and do what is right for you | #Entrepreneur | #Business | #Purpose | Bjorn Salsone | Nomalanga Sitole |The Voice Within #Podcast

      Dec 13, 2022 • 10.37

      There is only one YOU, so just be yourself! We keep hearing this, so why are you still trying to be someone or something else. Bjorn Salsone chats to serial, award winning entrepreneur Nomalanga Sitole. Nomalanga Sitole is a multi-award-winning South African entrepreneur who is always looking for the next…

    • The

      The "F" word entrepreneurs hate - Finances | #Entrepreneur | #Finance | Business Brunch | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | ActionCoach | #Podcast

      Dec 9, 2022 • 18.03

      I am yet to meet an entrepreneur or business owner that says I love doing my finances. Unless of course you are a business accountant, that is.  Knowing your financial situation and financial goals is so key to your business success. Lets see how we can help you with this.…

    Most Recent Podcasts
    eBizRadio.com Online Radio
    eBizRadio.com Online Radio
    Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast
    00:00 / 1929
    RSS Feed
    Share
    Link
    Embed
    • Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast

      Figuring out your USP? | #Entrepreneur | #Business | Bjorn Salsone | Christian Harbeck | #Podcast

      Jan 30, 2023 • 1929

      A Unique Selling Proposition (USP) is a crucial aspect of any business that sets it apart from its competitors. It is the factor that makes a business memorable, trustworthy and desirable to its target market. Once a business owner has discovered their USP, they can offer their clients real and…

    • Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast

      Massive layoffs and how it affects business | #Marketing | #IT | Lunchtime Marketing | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast

      Jan 29, 2023 • 40.44

      The world is witnessing massive job losses in 2023, with tech-based companies being particularly impacted. Many organizations are announcing their intentions to lay off more staff, with the common reasons cited as the pandemic boom, over hiring during the pandemic, fear of recession, and inflation. Cost-cutting, subpar performance, and financial…

    • What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group

      What is a future ready workforce? | #HR | #Business | #Business | Lunchtime Coach | Kevin Britz | Natalie Davies | PLP Group

      Jan 25, 2023 • 33.40

      Handle your recruitment with care. Its hard to have those tough conversations with your team, but its how and where do you it that will make the difference. Welcome to the era of human leadership. According to a survey done by Gartner, 90% of HR execs believe that to be…

    • Preparing learners with the skills they need to take jobs in the future? | #Technology | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Lindi Tshabangu | Richard Osei-Anim | Coralreef Innovation Hub | #Podcast

      Preparing learners with the skills they need to take jobs in the future? | #Technology | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Lindi Tshabangu | Richard Osei-Anim | Coralreef Innovation Hub | #Podcast

      Jan 24, 2023 • 22.04

      While Automation is phasing out traditional job roles innovation is redefining these jobs and creating new ones. The burden of responsibility is thus placed on Education to prepare learners with the skills they need to take up these jobs of the future. Lindi Tshabangu, host of the entrepreneur show –…

    • How is AI and possibly ChatGPT disrupting marketing? | #Marketing | #AI | #ChatGPT | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee |  Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      How is AI and possibly ChatGPT disrupting marketing? | #Marketing | #AI | #ChatGPT | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Jan 20, 2023 • 37.54

      Is AI and possibly even ChatGPT the big disruptive movement in the marketing space? Kevin Britz and Craig Page-Lee, host the weekly Lunchtime Marketing show on www.ebizradio.com and for the first show of 2023, they delve into the big trends for 2023, particularly looking at AI.   Post Views: 3,439

    • Motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success | #Business | #Coaching | Kevin Britz | Desiree Wegner | The Holistic People Collective | #Podcast

      Motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success | #Business | #Coaching | Kevin Britz | Desiree Wegner | The Holistic People Collective | #Podcast

      Jan 19, 2023 • 35.34

      Periodically, we encounter difficulty in finding inspiration for our pursuits. Though there may be brief periods of motivation, it can eventually dissipate, causing us to fall behind in our goals. What many fail to realize is that motivation is a fundamental component in achieving success. Without it, there is no…

    • Teaching children emotional intelligence | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Word of Mouth | Lindi Tshabangu | Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali |  Zamangwane Foundation | #Podcast

      Teaching children emotional intelligence | #Entrepreneur | #Education | Word of Mouth | Lindi Tshabangu | Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali | Zamangwane Foundation | #Podcast

      Jan 17, 2023 • 24.20

      Social entrepreneur, author, teacher, mother and the epitome of Ubuntu.  How we can collectively assist our children to grow, develop, communicate and develop into emotionally intelligent, confident and secure your adults. Lindi Tshabangu connect with Zamangwane Thabethe Mtshali, founder of  Zamangwane Foundation to find out more about this entrepreneur, her…

    • Its time to re-evaluate your values | #Insight | #Business | Lunchtime Coaching | Kevin Britz | Kiona van Griensven

      Its time to re-evaluate your values | #Insight | #Business | Lunchtime Coaching | Kevin Britz | Kiona van Griensven

      Jan 16, 2023 • 32.39

      Are you tired of saying, I’m overwhelmed, I’m exhausted, how am I going to cope with and in business this year? You are so not alone, but we need to adjust and change  how we do things, what is important to us and how do we re-evaluate our entire business…

    • Stop it now! |#BrandActivism | #Marketing | #Branding | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Stop it now! |#BrandActivism | #Marketing | #Branding | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | Lunchtime Marketing | #Podcast

      Dec 15, 2022 • 41.40

      Brand activism is when a brand or business takes a stand on a social, environmental, economic, or political issue. It’s about supporting a cause that aligns with a company’s core values, communicating a commitment to creating a positive impact, and putting that commitment into action. Brand activism is what you…

    • Calling Us Home - The Musical - Meet the cast | #Entertainment | #Music | #Theatre | Bjorn Salsone | Devonecia Swartz | Michael Castillo | #Podcast

      Calling Us Home - The Musical - Meet the cast | #Entertainment | #Music | #Theatre | Bjorn Salsone | Devonecia Swartz | Michael Castillo | #Podcast

      Dec 15, 2022 • 15.57

      After a thrilling audition process and nationwide search in South Africa as well as New York, Shy Music are delighted to announce that the leading roles in Calling Us Home – The Musical have been confirmed for the premiere season in Cape Town in February 2023, before the grand-scale musical…

    Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
    © 2023 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Sign In or Register

    Welcome Back!

    Login below or Register Now.

    Please enter the correct answer: *


    Lost password?

    Register Now!

    Already registered? Login.

    Please enter the correct answer: *


    A password will be e-mailed to you.