The number of audit firms that are offering consulting and software development services to boost their revenues has been on the rise. Increasingly, these businesses are seizing opportunities to deliver consulting services across the board, including financial planning, tax, due diligence, HR, Information Technology, and suchlike.
The heads of CPA firms see consulting services as a means to give their clients additional value, as well as create new revenue streams. However, they are making a crucial mistake. They are managing these auditing services as if they were consulting practices, which could – and is – causing impact on audit integrity.
So says Richard Firth, CEO of MIP Holdings, who says this should be a major concern to the corporate governance community, boards, audit committees, and their legal teams, considering that key to the integrity of SA’s economy is auditor independence, which puts these services beyond reproach.
He adds that many of the most prominent audit firms have started to provide consulting services to their clients over the past few years, driving concerns that the auditor’s interest in developing or maintaining a non-audit services relationship with their customers could overtake their interest in the primary audit relationship. Moreover, investors are understandably worried that non-audit services, when given to an audit client, create core conflicts that fly in the face of auditor objectivity.
“I would love to see an industry statistic that denotes all listed companies where an audit partner has performed software development work on behalf of their client. Many audit companies can justify technology consultancy as a key delivery in a technology risk investigation and in terms of potential IT security risk aversion. However, when an audit firm provides development capability to a customer, is this not stretching the boundary of audit practises a little too far? I also believe that many of the consultancy practices provided by audit companies are stretching the ever-increasing grey area of audit,” Firth says.
Possibly the most scandalous allegation relating to an audit company is KPMG’s involvement in the wedding of one of the Gupta sons in 2013, which was purportedly funded by R30-million of South African taxpayers’ cash. This was allegedly done by funnelling funds that were meant for poor Free State farmers through Dubai and then bringing the funds back to the country through an organisation called Linkway Trading – a Gupta company. The family is alleged to have claimed these as business expenses, no income tax was paid, and the transactions were signed off by their auditors.
Firth says this is why several nations have put legislation in place to lower any risk of conflict of interest. In the USA, for example, accounting firms are not allowed to provide non-audit services to companies for which they perform audits.
“South African legislation or the audit industry needs to publish a definition of what audit should and should not entail. So far, the law isn’t so strict in South Africa, but given the scandals that have littered the headlines, I wouldn’t be surprised if that changes soon,” concludes Firth.
About MIP Holdings
MIP is the leading provider of affordable business/IT solutions to the financial services industry in emerging markets when measured by “number of lives covered”. Over 13 million policy holders experience MIP’s technology on a daily basis.
MIP is the world’s only software company delivering solutions across all of the financial service verticals. Its products and services are diversified to accommodate the specialised administration needs of health scheme administrations, managed healthcare, national health insurance, lending, employee benefits, individual life insurance (including funeral funds), group life insurance, motor vehicle maintenance and warrantee, legal insurance and company accounting.
MIP is also a leader in developing mobile apps for the financial services industry. The company’s specialist knowledge, gained in integrating mobile apps into organisations, is proving useful to any business wanting to build world-class mobile applications.
Read more about MIP’s Digital Stack on the Web site: www.mip.co.za.
Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
+27 11 575 1800
- Covid-19 lockdown spurs massive spike in new business account registrations online | #eBizInisghts| Jonathon Smit of Payfast |Podcast - May 29, 2020
- Insights on Data: Podcast 4 Data Literacy and Skills | #eBizInsights| Jayson O’Reilly|Podcast - May 27, 2020
- We’re facing a new way of connecting with consumers| #eBizInsights | Victor Koaho - May 27, 2020
- Types of Covid-19 tests explained| #eBizInsights | Gerald Naidoo - May 27, 2020
- The Marketing Research Foundation updates the industry| #eBizWires - May 27, 2020
- How do we get through this trauma? |#Lifestyle |#Monique Strydom| Podcast - May 22, 2020
- How to handle the unexpected news of retrenchment |#Insight |#Devan Moonsammy - May 19, 2020
- THERE IS NO RISK IN BEING DIFFERENT WHEN NOTHING IS THE SAME| #eBizInsights | Ursula McDonald & Pippa Capstick | Podcast - May 18, 2020
- Insights on Data Podcast 3: Data Analysis | #eBizInsights |Quinton Senekal - May 18, 2020
- Remote working during Lockdown | #eBizTechnology | Arthur Goldstuck | Podcast - May 11, 2020