I do not know about you, but these lock-down stages make no sense to me at all. They are a confusion of frameworks, rules, permissions, sectors, and formula’s that I cannot make head or tail of. How on earth do we move from a Stage 4 to a Stage 3 to Stage 2 to Stage 1?
We must be very clear that the ONLY reason for a lock-down is to reduce the spread of the virus by restricting human movement thus enabling the healthcare system to not become overwhelmed. The so called “flattening of the curve”. Aside from an extended total lock-down (and economic suicide) there is no other scenario other than a vaccine to stop a huge majority of our population getting this virus. It is inevitable.

But to understand this curve and the decisions that get made, we seem to be fixated on measuring the # of 1. Tests 2. Confirmed cases 3. Deaths and 4. Recoveries. With the number of deaths being the “freak out metric” given we have no context on how to view & evaluate these absolute numbers. Apparently 100 deaths are statistically an inflection point. What about 1,000 or 10,000? More seems bad. Let us freak out. And to that point – why aren’t we making more of the % of recoveries – surely a 97% recovery rate is far less fear inducing than a 3% death rate?
Unfortunately, these metrics give us information, but they do not give us insight and they certainly cannot in my opinion be a measure for a Lockdown Grading System from Phase 5 to Phase 1.
This is because it is inevitable that all these metrics will go up when you ease the lockdown and resume “normal” life. If the metrics go up (which they will) do, we scale back up to Phase 5?
It is complicated, prone to misinterpretation and heavy handedness, and I believe we need an alternative measure when it comes to lock-down and the decisions that are being made.
Surely, the metric the government needs to be measuring and communicating to us all is – PREPAREDNESS.
How PREPARED are we for this thing? That comes down to truly clear things that the government CAN control, and CAN communicate clearly and with authority. It is also a measurement any citizen can understand, and CAN change their behaviour around.
Surely if we reframe the Stages of the Lock-down around PREPAREDNESS everyone will understand the risks and the rewards of proper social distancing behaviour?
As a simple example, PREPAREDNESS can work with ratio’s (numbers made up for illustration purposes):
e.g. Ratio of Ventilators to People:
Stage 5 = no ventilators
Stage 4 = 1 ventilator to 1,000 people
Stage 3 = 10 ventilators to 1,000 people
Stage 2 = 100 ventilators to 1,000 people
Stage 1 = 1000 ventilators to 1,000 people
Or Face Masks to Population:
Stage 5 = 10m masks or 20% of population
Stage 4 = 20m masks or 40% of population
Stage 3 = 30m masks or 60% of population
Stage 2 = 40m masks or 80% of population
Stage 1 = 50m masks or 100% of population
You do the same with Sanitising stations, Hospital beds, Face Shields, Vaccines etc across all the stages and in the correct ratios to form a combined PREPAREDNESS score or index and use that so we can all understand.
It is a clear and measurable set of metrics and if we are PREPARED and meet the overall score, we go DOWN a level because the health care system can handle it. If we do not, we need to stay there, until Citizens, Private Business and government mobilise around the missing pieces with say Citizens focusing on Face Masks & sanitisers, Government tackling hospital beds, Private Business sorting Ventilators, Pharma sorting vaccines etc
With one common, easily understood and easily communicated metric both Government, Private Business & Citizens can then focus their efforts and budgets on getting PREPARED rather than just being SCARED?
Behind the scenes – Jason Harrison is a partner and group Managing Director of M&C Saatchi Abel – www.mcsaatchiabel.co.za
- Weekly News Roundup | #News | The Week that Was | Kuhle Tshabalala | #Podcast - August 19, 2022
- Retailers – get ready to thrive in the post-pandemic landscape as worldwide e-commerce sales exceed $5 trillion | #Insight | #Retail | Steven Heilbron | Capital Connect - August 19, 2022
- TikTok are rocking consumer segmentation | #Marketing | #Leadership | Lunchtime Series | Kevin Britz | Craig Page-Lee | #Podcast - August 18, 2022
- Opening a business in South Africa? | #Insight | Business Brunch | Bjorn Salsone | Ankita Vyas Bohra | Indiana House - August 18, 2022
- Weekly Motoring | Diesel and Dust | #Motoring | #Motorcycles | Tumelo Maketekete | #Podcast - August 18, 2022
- Why is EQ so important? | #Insight | #Coaching | #Business | #Leadership | Kevin Britz | Anja van Beek | #Podcast - August 17, 2022
- When can South African stop eating meat? | #Insight | Big Fish Stories | Eitan Stern | Brett Thompson | Mzansi Meat Co | #Podcast - August 17, 2022
- Why getting LinkedIn right is vital for your career | #Insights | Change Conversations | Mpume Ncube-Daka | Nompumelelo Mshengu | #Podcast - August 17, 2022
- The strain of holding the sword by the blade: The health and well-being of women in our poorest communities | #Insights | Charmaine Gola | The Love Trust - August 16, 2022
- What do architects actually do? | #BusinesBrunch | #Business | #Entrepreneur | Bjorn Salsone | Michelle Maltz Shevelew | M2S Architects | #Podcast - August 16, 2022